@Neal Cassady: Belated thanks for sharing your info and yt links for Nathan Shineywater's "Reach the Oldest Tree," a recording that purportedly has Hope Sandoval and Colm O'Ciosoig on it. I'm glad you solved the mystery of "Does Hope sing on this Shineywater release?" Now we know she doesn't. I enjoyed listening to your yt uploads of the cassette. I like all three songs.
I'd thought odds were likely low Hope sang on it as surely someone would have picked up on the fact some time since 2010 and made mention of it online somewhere.
There still remains one mystery though, imo: Do Hope & Colm appear on that recording in any capacity? After doing more research, I've become skeptical Hope is playing anything on the recording at all. Instruments she typically plays on her own recordings are mostly harmonica, tambourine, shakers, glockenspiel, and sometimes guitar and keyboards, uncredited. Keyboards seem the only possible Hope instrument on Shineywater's recording. She played glockenspiel on the song "Harmony" by Le Volume Courbe, but that's the only example I know of of Hope playing an instrument, rather than just singing, on someone else's record.
Discogs site shows two different cassette releases of the e.p. "Reach the Oldest Tree," one from 2009 and one from 2010. They have identical track listings of the same three songs. The 2009 one credits just two musicians, Rachel Grimes for piano, and Shineywater for voice, flute, keyboards, and percussion. The 2010 one includes a credit for "Berry Shadows," but doesn't credit Hope or Colm.
It was this comment or "review" left at the Discogs site page for the 2010 cassette that started me wondering if Hope maybe sings on it, QUOTE: "B Side of the tape is by Nathan Shineywater's new band called Berry Shadows. Berry Shadows is a band made up of N Shineywater, Hope Sandoval, Colm O'Cossaig (my bloody valentine) and others." I've since learned that comment is misleading.
Are the two cassettes identical except for the "Berry Shadows" reference on the 2010 release, I wonder? But if Hope and Colm were on the 2009 cassette, why did Shineywater not credit them? If Hope & Colm were not on the 2009 release, would Shineywater recruit them to re-record the very same songs for a 2010 release? Seems doubtful. And why would he not credit them by name on the 2010 release, if they were on it?
The comment left at discogs page for the 2010 cassette is misleading (it misled me) because it suggests Berry Shadows = Shineywater + Sandoval + O Ciosoig + "others." But that's not true.
Some 2010 articles mention the band Berry Shadows, but it's in reference to the band Shineywater was touring Australia with in April, 2010, a band that had nothing to do with Hope & Colm. Several original members of Shineywater's previous band Brightblack Morning Light had either quit (including his main BML partner Rachael Hughes), or were unavailable. Apparently, Shineywater had decided to retire the name Brightblack Morning Light and call his new project(s) going forward Berry Shadows. Tour posters for the 2010 Australian tour advertised "Brightblack Morning Light as Berry Shadows."
I'm guessing the "Berry Shadows" name or credit appears on the 2010 release of "Reach the Oldest Tree" but not on the 2009 one because Shineywater had, as described in the press, by 2010 decided to start using Berry Shadows as a name on projects and bands going forward.
A number of press articles/interviews from March-April 2010 from the time of Shineywater's 2010 Australian tour announce Shineywater was then currently working with or was soon to be working with Hope Sandoval (plus Colm O' Ciosoig, according to one report) on a collaborative 7" Berry Shadows vinyl single to be released. Evidently, Shineywater was announcing this collaboration to various press outlets. Which means he did not intend for Hope and Colm to appear on his recording incognito, anonymously, or uncredited. So, why would he leave them uncredited on the "Reach The Oldest Tree" cassette if they were actually on it?
I think the most likely scenario is a Berry Shadows collaboration with Hope and Colm (a 7" vinyl single), was planned but was never completed or never released. And that some people mistakenly thought The Reach The Oldest Tree cassette WAS the supposed collaboration with Hope and Colm, when in fact they likely did not appear on that recording at all.
Your yt uploads don't give the title of the "Reach The Oldest Tree" cassette, or give names of songs. How come? Many thanks again for sharing your recordings and helping solve a mystery!
PRESS QUOTES:
[April 2, 2010] "On the eve of Brightblack Morning Light’s first Australian tour, founder Nathan Shineywater has announced that this will be the last Brightblack Morning Light tour and the debut of his new musical identity, Berry Shadows. [Note ashbeesfragments site shows a pic of a 2010 Australian tour poster that reads: "Brightblack Morning Light as Berry Shadows"]. The new project Berry Shadows finds our man Shineywater deep in “freak” exploration and psychedelic spirit anthems. The first unofficial Berry Shadows shows took place in 2009 in San Francisco and Humboldt County, California, opening for Hope Sandoval & The Warm Inventions. Berry Shadows will soon be working and recording with Hope Sandoval; look out for a collaborative release between Mistletone Records and Hearted Hand Limited."
http://ashbeesfragments.com/2010/04/bri ... y-shadows/[April 8, 2010] "Brightblack Morning Light (formerly known as Brightblack and previously, rainYwood, and now moving towards the new incarnation of Berry Shadows) is a band based in New Mexico, specialising in permutations of folk rock and psychedelic music; the work of ND Shineywater and an ever-changing & rotating touring party of old friends & new friends who enjoy what they do. Recording their debut in 2005 for Matador Records, Brightblack Morning Light toured with Os Mutantes, Vashti Bunyan and Joanna Newsom, and more recently with My Bloody Valentine and Hope Sandoval & The Warm Inventions."
https://www.ilxor.com/ILX/ThreadSelecte ... id=1202143[March 23, 2010] On the eve of Brightblack Morning Light’s first Australian tour, founder Nathan Shineywater has announced that this will be the last Brightblack Morning Light tour and the debut of his new musical identity, Berry Shadows. [Note ashbeesfragments site shows a pic of an Australian tour poster that reads: "Brightblack Morning Light as Berry Shadows"].The new project Berry Shadows finds our man Shineywater deep in “freak” exploration and psychedelic spirit anthems. The first unofficial Berry Shadows shows took place in 2009 in San Francisco and Humboldt County, California, opening for Hope Sandoval & The Warm Inventions. Berry Shadows is currently recording with Hope Sandoval, Colm O’Ciosoig (My Bloody Valentine/Hope Sandoval & The Warm Inventions) and Daniel Higgs (Lungfish), and will release a 7" vinyl single soon, a collaborative release between Mistletone Records and Hearted Hand Limited."
https://musicfeeds.com.au/news/brightbl ... oast-tour/[date unknown] "Recent 2009 autumn shows included Shineywater with a new BBML backing band opening for HOPE SANDOVAL & THE WARM INVENTIONS both in San Francisco & in Humboldt County."
https://arthurmag.com/tag/hope-sandoval/[April 1, 2010] "Shineywater is retiring BBML. His new magic carpet is called Berry Shadows, featuring recording guests including Hope Sandoval. So this tour will be the last outing for BBML and minus the co-founder, Rachael Hughes. Instead Shineywater and his flotilla of souped-up vintage keyboards will be joined by accompanist Danielle Stech-Homsy (aka Rio en Medio) and Sioux percussionist, Cannupa...
[Interviewer]: Right. So. Then. Will you be playing much BBML material?
''No maaan,'' he says. ''But I think if people dig BBML, I think they'll find Berry Shadows a little bit more, you know? I think Berry Shadows is a newer jam still inspired by Alabama blues. But it's also a development of four years of living in Pueblo country and playing psychedelic live experiences. I guess for me it's been groovy, man.''"
https://www.smh.com.au/entertainment/mu ... -relj.html[April 13, 2010]: "Apparently on this tour Shineywater is simultaneously retiring BML and presenting his new musical incarnation – Berry Shadows – which will feature more collaborative work with people like Hope Sandoval whose voice will be perfect for these hazy, shimmering sounds. This show was probably more a look to where Shineywater is heading rather than where he has been, especially as it didn’t feature BBML’s co-founder Rachael Hughes."
https://doubtfulsounds.net/tag/berry-shadows/[March 23, 2010]: On the eve of Brightblack Morning Light’s first Australian tour, the band’s ever-mystic founder Nathan Shineywater has announced that this will be the last Brightblack Morning Light tour and the debut of his new musical identity, Berry Shadows. Mistletone will release an exclusive 7" vinyl Berry Shadows single, featuring Shineywater and collaborators Hope Sandoval, Colm O’Ciosoig (My Bloody Valentine/Hope Sandoval & The Warm Inventions) and Daniel Higgs (Lungfish)."
https://musicfeeds.com.au/news/brightbl ... oast-tour/